We think of something being abundant as a great thing.
Food, water, housing, money -- the more the better.
Counterintuitively, that abundance makes us fragile to shocks in the system.
Water is a great example.
What place is better off a city in the arid desert like Albuquerque, NM or right here in Crozet, Virginia? At first glance it is the Piedmont region of VA with its abundance of surface water compared to the lack of it in the desert. The abundance of water however makes the community more vulnerable to shocks.
This last summer we saw it.
Draught and our surface water reservoirs went down by dozens of feet. That will always be the case because water is abundant and droughts are temporary. We don't change behavior for temporary blips on the radar.
Behavior is cultural and that takes years and decades to change.
In a place like ABQ where water is treated like a deadly game of chess the systems are in place to handle a summer of drought without much fuss. More importantly they look into the future with uncertainty on that resource and think of it as scarce.
The thought of scarcity changes behavior. A more resilient behavior.
So the argument goes that the abundance of water makes Crozet more fragile to climate change in the future than a place like ABQ. People see the abundance, move there, treat it like it is forever and when there is a shock it is devastating.
But the answer isn't in being another dummy and going around with water conservation platitudes demonstrating moral superiority.
This is to understand where your strengths really lie.
Things that are scarce, diminishing, and not guaranteed help you put systems in place to go without.
Years ago as a defense contractor my job was always year to year. Every August the option year came up and it was at the largesse of the government to exercise another year. So every year I saved money and put out my resume to find other jobs because next year was not guaranteed. That scarcity made me look for other jobs, some of those other jobs were for higher positions for more money.
I became very good at those two actions and saw first hand others who got devastated. They didn't do as well in interviews because they were not practiced or fragile to the shock of not having an income and taking the first job offered even if that meant less money -- they HAD to take it, they were fragile.
Thinking that the guaranteed government job with a high salary seems like a strength but it changes our behavior and that behavior change makes us fragile.
So there is a strong argument to make that if you think climate change will be drastic and everywhere will be effected that you should move to a place that is already scare in those resources. Those are the communities will be the most likely to handle changes that occur in the future.
Hard to do because abundance is a great thing to have -- right?
Where do you have abundance in your life that makes you fragile to shocks? Where do your strengths really lie?